Your Most Regularly Requested Pie Crust Questions Answered

This put up could comprise affiliate hyperlinks. Please see my full disclosure for particulars.

Hello Daring Bakers!

After years of gathering up a lot data, we created some paperwork that may enable you make ice cream, cookies, desserts, cheesecakes, and extra!

On this complete Pastry Q&A put up, I’ve your pie crust questions answered. Ask me something that’s lacking within the feedback and I’ll reply!

Q: Which flour is greatest for making pie crust?

A: There are two major varieties of flour generally used for pie crusts: all-purpose flour and pastry flour. Right here’s a quick comparability of the 2:

Versatility: All-purpose flour is essentially the most versatile and extensively obtainable sort of flour. It’s appropriate for quite a lot of baking wants, together with pie crusts.

Texture: Its reasonable quantity of protein leads to a young but barely flaky crust.

Pastry flour has a decrease protein content material than all-purpose flour, which makes it preferrred for creating exceptionally tender and delicate pie crusts.

Pastry flour is commonly beneficial for a young, melt-in-your-mouth crust. It’s generally used for delicate pastries and tarts.

In abstract, the “greatest” flour for making a pie crust will depend on your choice for texture. If you need a flakier, extra delicate crust, pastry flour could also be your alternative. In the event you favor a crust that’s barely sturdier however nonetheless tender, all-purpose flour is an efficient choice. Some bakers additionally experiment with a mixture of each flours to attain a stability between tenderness and flakiness. Self-raising flour and cake flour aren’t beneficial.

Q: What’s pastry flour, and may I take advantage of that for pie crust?

A: Pastry flour is a kind of wheat flour that’s milled from smooth wheat varieties, particularly chosen for his or her decrease protein content material in comparison with all-purpose flour’s exhausting wheat.

The decrease protein content material in pastry flour makes it preferrred for a young and delicate texture. Listed below are some key traits and makes use of of pastry flour:

• Pastry flour sometimes accommodates about 8% to 9% protein, which is considerably decrease than all-purpose flour (often round 11% protein) and bread flour (round 12-14% protein). This leads to a young, crumbly, and delicate texture, particularly well-suited for pastries, pie crusts, tarts, cookies, and biscuits.
• Pastry flour is often lighter in coloration which helps preserve the specified look of baked items.
• In the event you don’t have pastry flour available, you possibly can create an in depth approximation by mixing all-purpose flour and cake flour in equal components. This mix will mimic the decrease protein content material of pastry flour.
• Whereas pastry flour will not be as generally present in grocery shops as all-purpose flour, it’s available in lots of well-stocked supermarkets and specialty shops, or you should buy it on-line. General, pastry flour is a superb alternative while you wish to obtain a smooth, tender crumb in your baked items, particularly in recipes the place a fragile texture is crucial, akin to for pie crusts and sure varieties of pastries.

Q: Is obvious flour the identical as all-purpose flour?

A: Sure! It’s a standard wheat flour with a protein content material of 8-11%. It’s referred to as “all-purpose flour” within the US and Canada as a result of it really works in a variety of baked items, together with desserts, cookies, muffins, fast breads, pastries, pies, pancakes and waffles.

It’s referred to as “plain flour” within the UK, Australia, Eire and another nations as a result of it doesn’t comprise any leavening agent.

Q: Can I take advantage of entire wheat flour when making pie crust?

A: Sure,I like to recommend utilizing at max 50% entire wheat flour and 50% white flour to make pie crust.  Nonetheless, the consequence will probably be denser and fewer flaky as a result of presence of bran that weighs down the protein and impacts the rise.

Q: Are you able to make pastry dough utilizing gluten-free flour?

A: Sure, you should utilize an all-purpose gluten-free flour combine in a 1:1 substitution. Observe to carry again some liquid through the use of as much as 3/4 in a single go and adjusting it accordingly to get the identical consistency as mine.

Q: Can I take advantage of Home made Butter when making pastries?

A: Sure, you possibly can! Actual butter yields the very best, flakey leads to your pie crust.

Q: Can you employ whipped or spreadable butter when making pastry dough?

A: No, you possibly can’t. Spreadable butter or whipped butter often accommodates extra water , oil or cream for a softer consistency. Whipped butter additionally accommodates further air. so utilizing any of those will trigger the ratios to be off, yielding totally different leads to texture and taste.

Q: Ought to I take advantage of salted butter or unsalted butter when making pastry dough?

A: You need to use both because the quantity of salt in salted butter. Numerous it comes down to private choice. I favor salted butter as a result of slight added taste however some bakers like utilizing unsalted butter gives you extra management of the salt in your pastry. I’ll go away it as much as you. My 2 cents is that I’ve by no means heard anybody complain that my baked items had been too salty.

Q: Can I take advantage of half lard and half butter in pastry dough?

A: Sure, you possibly can! Utilizing half of every fats will kind the neutrality benefiting each candy and savory pies in taste, texture, look, dealing with and storage :

• Lard is a rendered pork fats with a impartial taste permitting the opposite elements to shine by way of. Butter: Butter has a wealthy, creamy, and distinctly buttery taste which works notably nicely in candy pies.
• Lard has the next melting level than butter, which may also help create layers within the crust, leading to a flakier pastry. Butter  has a decrease melting level than lard making the crust barely extra crumbly and tender in comparison with lard-based crusts.
• Lard makes pie crusts paler whereas butter balances it nicely with a barely golden tone from the butter’s pure yellow coloration.
• Butter is extra delicate to temperature and may soften or soften rapidly whereas lard generally is a bit extra forgiving and may make it simpler to work with and to take care of pie crusts’  integrity in heat environments.

Q: Why do recipes ask you to grate frozen butter for pie crust?

A: Utilizing frozen butter in Pie crust is to maximise the truth that water from frozen butter will evaporate throughout baking to make air pockets creating layers. This makes the flakiest pie crust.  If the butter is just not chilly sufficient, it means a part of its water content material has already evaporated into the air earlier than going into the oven.

You’ll be able to grate butter when you’ve got time and blend it with some flour then freeze these butter curls. Very useful. Bake anytime you need and your butter is bound to be chilly sufficient each time!

Q: How can I measure frozen butter?

A: The simplest method is to measure it earlier than you freeze it. If the recipe requires grated butter then additionally I like to recommend measuring the block first, then grate.

Q: How do dairy merchandise akin to buttermilk, bitter cream, and yogurt have an effect on pie crust?

A: These dairy elements can have barely totally different results on the feel and taste of the pie crust, so it’s vital to decide on the one which fits your choice. Right here’s how every of those dairy merchandise can have an effect on a pie crust:

• Dairy merchandise present moisture to the pastry dough, preserving the crust tender and from getting overly dry.
• Fats (particularly in bitter cream) coats the particles of flour, inhibiting the formation of gluten, leading to a smooth and crumbly texture. In the intervening time, fats additionally provides richness and flavors to pastry. The acid interferes with the protein’s potential to bond collectively successfully. This makes the dough extra tender. Taste-wise, the delicate tang can stability and improve the general style of the pastry.
• You’ll want to try my simple recipes that work like surprise: Home made Buttermilk, Home made Bitter Cream, and Home made Yogurt.

Q: Why do you add vodka to pie crust?

A: Laborious spirits (vodka, whiskeys and so on) are usually 40% to 60% alcohol (most down round 40) with 40% to 60% being water. Substituting alcohol for water means much less evaporation throughout baking therefore much less possibilities of crust shrinking.

• Alcohol doesn’t contribute to forming a gluten community as water does, so it makes it simpler to roll the crust with out toughening it.
• Basically, you possibly can substitute alcohol for half or all of the required quantity of water, at a 1:1 ratio. It’s greatest to start out with 1 tablespoon of exhausting spirits in a 9-10 inch pie crust. Alter it accordingly to get the specified taste and the identical consistency as the unique recipe. However be cautious to not add an excessive amount of, as extreme liquid could make the dough overly moist and difficult to work with.

Q: Why do you add lemon juice to pie crust?

A: Lemon juice is usually included in pie crusts or puff pastry for taste, texture and coloration:

• Lemon juice provides a delicate tartness to brighten and refresh the crust.
• The acidity inhibits gluten formation, which may tenderize the crust dough.
• Lemon juice may also help preserve the paleness of the crust which can go well with sure pies in look.

Q: Why do all of your elements should be chilly when making pie crust

A: Utilizing chilly elements akin to butter, water, and flour (even chilly bowls and utensils) when making pie crust is an important step in flakiness, tenderness, higher management, and discount of shrinkage.

• Utilizing chilly fats helps make sure that it doesn’t soften prematurely through the mixing course of however relatively throughout baking, creating pockets of steam that develop and separate the layers therefore contributing to the specified flakiness.
• Chilly elements assist inhibit gluten formation, leading to a extra tender crust.
• Chilly elements make it simpler to manage the feel of the dough. You’ll be able to manipulate the chilly fats into the flour extra exactly, guaranteeing that it’s evenly distributed and coated with flour. This even distribution of fats contributes to a constant and predictable pie crust.
• When the pie crust is positioned in a scorching oven, the chilly fats quickly melts and creates steam, which helps set the form of the crust earlier than it has an opportunity to shrink.

Q: How do you make a half pastry dough recipe?

A: Divide every ingredient by 2 and comply with the recipe as regular.

Q: Are you able to freeze pie crust?

A: Sure, you possibly can freeze pie crust and it’s a useful step in pie making:

• Freezing the pie crust helps make sure that the fats is at its coldest, which, when it melts throughout baking, creates steam and varieties essentially the most layers, leading to a young, flaky pastry.
• Freezing the pie crust may also help forestall it from shrinking. When the crust is frozen, it’s much less more likely to lose its form because it begins to bake.
• Freezing can create a barrier between the filling and the crust, stopping the crust from getting soggy.
• Freezing pie crust can be time-saving and handy particularly for baking a number of pies without delay.

Q: What does Blind baking imply?

A: Baking blind is the strategy used to bake a pie crust or different pastry with out the filling both solely partially baked or absolutely baked.

• Some pies want a bit further pre-baked love so that they don’t get soggy. Blind baking is commonly used for pies which have a really moist filling like a Pumpkin Pie or a Pecan Pie. Blind baking a pie crust can be needed when it will likely be stuffed with an unbaked filling, wherein case the crust have to be absolutely baked like fruit tarts or a Chocolate Pudding Pie.
• Study extra particulars in my article of Find out how to Blind Bake a Pie Crust.

Q: What can I take advantage of if I don’t have ‘baking beads’

A: Line the pie crust with a big piece of parchment and fill it with dry beans, uncooked rice, or lentils to cease the dough from rising up because it bakes. Save the rice/beans for use time and again in your future pies!

Q: How far prematurely can I blind bake my pie crust ?

A: There’re a couple of methods to blind bake a pie crust:

• You’ll be able to blind bake a pie crust on the identical day of serving. Observe to permit half-hour to 1 hour to chill the crust for additional makes use of.This can make sure the crust is contemporary and crisp when it’s time to serve.
• You too can blind bake the crust a day forward. After blind baking, permit the crust to chill fully, then cowl it with plastic wrap or foil and retailer it at room temperature till you’re able to assemble your pie. This could prevent time on the day you intend to serve the pie.

Q: What’s the most effective temperature to bake pie crust at?

A: Most pastries like HOT ovens. The most effective temperature to bake a pie crust can range relying on the kind of pie and the recipe you’re utilizing. Basically, pie crusts are sometimes baked at temperatures starting from 375°F (190°C) to 425°F (220°C). Listed below are some normal pointers:

• Pre-baking a crust (blind baking): In the event you’re making a pie that requires a pre-baked crust, like a custard pie, quiche, or a pie with a no-bake filling, you’ll usually bake with pie weights at 350°F (180°C) till the dough appears to be like matte as a substitute of moist, about 20 minutes. In the event you want your pastry absolutely baked then take away the parchment paper and weights and bake for an additional 10-Quarter-hour or till the underside of the crust is simply calmly golden. Then proceed to bake with filling in in response to your pie recipe.
• Fruit pies: For many fruit pies, akin to apple, cherry, or blueberry, the frequent baking temperature is round 350°F(180°C) to 375°F (190°C). This decrease temperature permits the filling to prepare dinner completely with out over-browning the crust.
• Savory pies: Savory pies like pot pies, mushroom parcels, or meat pies could also be baked at temperatures just like fruit pies, often round 375°F (190°C).
• Cream and custard pies: Cream pies and custard pies, like pumpkin pies or pecan pies, are sometimes baked at round 350°F (180°C) to 400°F (200°C), to make sure that the filling units correctly with out overcooking the crust.
• Hand pies and turnovers: Smaller pies, akin to hand pies or turnovers, are sometimes baked at a barely increased temperature, usually round 375°F (190°C)-400°F (200°C), to attain a crisp, golden crust.

Q: Ought to I bake pastry utilizing the convection setting on my oven or the common setting?

A: Most of my recipes are based mostly on a traditional typical oven (except specified in any other case) with out utilizing a fan or prime heating components.

• Bake on the center rack generally. So you should utilize the standard baking perform following my recipe or use the convection oven baking (with fan) by reducing the temperature by roughly 25°F or following the producer’s guide.
• In case your oven is comparatively smaller than a fuel vary oven like an OTG (oven toaster grill), you do want further consideration to see whether or not extra changes are wanted. I solely use fan help in my oven when I’m baking a number of issues without delay. This permits the recent air to flow into evenly whereas baking.
• An air fryer works like a convection oven which is fan assisted with heating components on the ceiling contained in the baking chamber . It’s best to decrease your temperature by about 25°F(15°C) in comparison with the recipe or comply with the guide directions. Try my articles Understanding Your Toaster Oven (A Information To OTG Baking) and Information to Knowing Your Oven to know and management your oven higher.

Q: How do I do know which pie crust recipe to make use of for my pie?

A: Which pie crust to make use of will depend on a number of elements, together with the kind of pie you’re making and your private preferences.

• My Greatest-Ever Pie Crust is a flexible grasp recipe that may enable you make candy pie crust completely, each time, akin to, The Solely Blueberry Pie Recipe You’ll Want, Greatest-Ever Pecan Pie,  or my Traditional Cherry Pie. Additionally works nice while you wish to do  5 Spectacular & Straightforward Pie Designs.
• My Buttermilk Pie Crust substituting buttermilk for water not solely makes this pie crust ten occasions extra flakey and tender but additionally amplifies the crust’s taste making the crust its personal scrumptious element. You need to use this crust both candy or savory however I personally find it irresistible for my Tomato and Ricotta Galette , Mushroom and Thyme Leaf Tart and particularly my Quiche recipe.
• My Flaky Bitter Cream Pie Crust changed water with bitter cream including each tenderness and depth of taste. It’s a lot flaky and tender than customary pie crusts and richer than buttermilk pie crust. You need to use this pie crust for candy and savory pies.
• My 5-Minute No-Roll Pie Crust does NOT require rolling and is made by mixing all elements and pushing the dough in the identical pan that’s for baking it! It’s a straightforward path with the identical wonderful flaky outcomes. You already know what goes into your curst so it’s more healthy than store-bought crusts at a decrease price! You’ll be able to blind bake it, freeze it, or use it in any of my pie recipes.
• My Completely Savory Pie Crust has a beneficiant quantity of butter — yielding an ideal flake that may truly work for each candy and savory pies. Strive it in my Thanksgiving Leftover Pie!
• My Gluten-Free Pie Crust recipe is the simplest, flakiest, gluten-free crust you’ll discover on the market, and it’s excellent for all bakers — be it gluten sensitivity, curiosity, and even utilizing simply what you might need on-hand. Get pleasure from it in my Gluten-Free Cherry Almond Tart or use it in my Pumpkin Pie or my fav American Buttermilk Pie.