On Monday, we shared with you our greatest beer experiences of 2024. None of these experiences included our greatest beers of the yr, which works to point out (once more) how a lot placement and timing can have an effect on how we work together with a beverage.
These beers run the gamut from low-ABV desk beer to huge barrel-aged stout, and from a resurgent brewery to a hopefully-returning-soon collaboration from two breweries you will not be aware of (but).
It was a great yr of consuming. Right here’s what we thought have been tops:
Steve’s Greatest Beer: Windmill’s Luelle
As beer types go, West Coast IPAs are my go-to. I’m kinda over hazies, I’m nonetheless a sucker for a pastry stout and can by no means say no to a Helles lager. All of that’s to say that I by no means anticipated my favourite beer of 2024 to be a desk beer. Heck, I’m undecided I knew precisely what a desk beer was when Windmill Brewing dropped Luelle in Might, simply weeks earlier than they closed their doorways.
Head brewer Jake Edwards – now brewing at Open Outcry – named it after his new child daughter and described the three.8% beer as “a farmhouse-style desk beer brewed with orange peel and grains of paradise.”
I nonetheless bear in mind my first sip, pausing earlier than declaring, “That’s a lovely beer.” An odd response, maybe, but it surely was mild, pretty and packed a lot taste into one thing with so little ABV, it shortly turned a go-to this summer season. Right here’s hoping Jake’s new associates on the South Facet get an opportunity to expertise “LuLu.”
Eric’s Greatest Beer: Goose Island BCBS Uncommon 2024
My favourite beer I had all yr didn’t come till late October, once I received to do this yr’s Uncommon on the Bourbon County tasting at Salt Shed. It instantly was the standout of the seven beers we sampled that night time. The one largest differentiator amongst non-adjuncted BCS choices for years has been the kind of barrel used.
Goose received their arms on some uncommon King of Kentucky bourbon barrels and brewed up a stout to face up to the slumber in wooden. I received to attempt it once more at Fulton on Black Friday whereas there muling for somebody and I used to be fortunate sufficient to seize two extra bottles: one to drink and one to commerce. There’s so a lot barrel.
The thrill and restricted availability to this point1 have most beer nerds exterior Chicago questioning what all of the fuss is about. I believe this particular beer might be in contrast to 2015 Uncommon, which you can discover at Goal a yr later. Contemplate this one really uncommon.
Ryan’s Greatest Beer: Ellison Brewery’s Tiramisu Stout
To understand my favourite beer of the yr it’s essential to grasp the place behind it. Ellison Brewery first opened in 2015, a yr after we uprooted from Chicago and moved to mid-Michigan. This was the closest brewery to our home, had free popcorn which instantly made it child pleasant, and had a unbelievable lineup of stouts and IPAs.
It turned our go-to brewery to take associates once they have been visiting, a spot to seize a beer whereas operating weekend errands or for the occasional ladies or guys nights out. For Christmas in 2019 I used to be even gifted a mug membership membership. After which COVID occurred.
A number of companies struggled via these first a number of months, and I attempted to do my half making journeys each two weeks to snag beer or spirits – or typically each. Within the ensuing couple of years issues have been totally different there. The regular rotation of beers we got here to like weren’t all the time on draft, the brewery closed for a spell throughout renovations and a second location in Lansing shuttered in 2023.
I don’t know the why behind it, however for a time, Ellison had develop into a shell of its former self. Which is why I used to be thrilled to seek out the brewery I first latched onto as my native brewery (very like I did with Half Acre and Begyle again in Chicago) had a resurgence this yr.
Ellison’s lineup of stouts is unparalleled, and their Tiramisu Stout could also be the most effective of the bunch. It’s equal elements candy and roasty with out being an over-the-top pastry stout. A number of sips jogged my memory of why I fell in love with the brewery almost a decade in the past.
Karl’s Greatest Beer: Gnosis & Knack’s Gnack Lager
I don’t observe the beers that I drink on Untappd or BeerAdvocate or something like that. As an alternative, once I like a specific beer, I take a photograph of it on my cellphone. As I used to be scrolling via my photographs app to remind myself of what I drank this yr, I ended brief on one picture that sums up what I actually like in a beer at this level in my life: Gnack.

In July, Steve kindly despatched me just a few cans from breweries within the NWI area, together with two tallboys of Gnack. He knew I’d love this English brown lager, saying additionally that “my thoughts was blown by how good it’s.” And he was proper!
Made by Merrilville’s Gnosis Brewing and Kankakee’s Knack Brewing & Fermentations, it takes a seamless mixture of every thing I like a couple of good English-style delicate ale – mild, bittersweet, delicate and wealthy on the identical time – and musically transposes it into a beer key, making it even simpler consuming and approachable.
And although we’re in a renaissance of scrumptious darkish lagers, this one walked an impressively delicate tightrope of taste — not as sharply roasty as a Czech darkish nor as candy as a Dunkel — whereas working within the framework of a dry, grassy, frivolously earthy English type. I beloved it.
I had a variety of actually good beers this yr. I’ve a variety of good beers chilling in my fridge proper now for NYE functions. I’m fairly fortunate, and I drink fairly nicely. And I actually want I had a few of this again in my fridge once more proper now. Right here’s hoping it returns subsequent Might.
(Runner up for me this yr is the Liquid Spirit porter on cask that I had at Brass Ring Brewing, so clearly, I’ve transitioned into simply full-on malt adoration man this yr.)
What have been your favourite beers of the yr? Tell us within the feedback (open to all!) or hit us up on our socials. See y’all on Monday once we get again to common enterprise.
1 …which was simply Uncommon Day, the Black Friday pre-ordered packages, a handful bottles that offered out in about an hour at Fulton [and possibly Salt Shed] the identical day after which just a few extra bottles on the twenty third.
Extra From Guys Consuming Beer
Our Greatest Beers of 2024
December 31, 2024
Our Greatest Beer Experiences of 2024
December 30, 2024
FoBAB 2024 Reflections
November 30, 2024
Our 2024 Bourbon County Stout Opinions & Rankings
November 16, 2024
Wolfden Brewing Firm: America’s Most Haunted Brewery?
October 31, 2024
The GABF 2024 Roundup of Nice Lakes Medal Winners
October 14, 2024
In regards to the Writer