Joe’s Pizza Nanticoke – NEPA Pizza Evaluate

Joe’s Pizza Nanticoke is a small pizzeria that’s wealthy in historical past. The pizza is implausible, and also you’re all the time positive to have an amazing dialog with the proprietor, Joe. He’s a one man operation. Joe loves to speak and work together along with his clients and share tales. He learns about you and your loved ones and by no means forgets you. He remembered me and my spouse after practically 10 years after I stopped in lately! Make sure you preserve scrolling to learn that 2014 expertise on the backside of this text!

I teamed up with Bob Kalinowski of The Nanticoke Newsroom to go on a “Pizza Tour” of Nanticoke. The journey included 4 of Nanticoke’s oldest pizza making institutions. We visited Ruby’s Inn, Nardozzo’s Pizzeria, Joe’s Pizza, and Larry’s Pizza and Pub. It was an amazing day stuffed with scrumptious pizza and nice dialog. The homeowners, staffs, and clients had been all fantastic individuals. It was so fascinating to listen to how these companies all assist each other. It was additionally refreshing to find out about how dedicated the parents of Nanticoke are to historical past and telling tales about their roots. Actually cool city, wonderful individuals, and nice pizza with distinctive traits all over the place!

Evaluating/Contrasting Joe’s Traditional and Artigiano Pizzas

Throughout this tour cease, we tried Joe’s basic and Artigiano pizzas. He defined to us that each pizzas had been constituted of the very same elements: identical dough, sauce, and cheese. However taking a look at every pizza and tasting them, you wouldn’t essentially know that. Just a few tweaks in proportions, preparation, and baking technique creates a wholly completely different expertise.

Each pizzas characteristic a skinny, crispy, and durable crust with no flop. They each have a barely candy and savory easy sauce that’s vibrant and scrumptious. They usually each use a cheese with a loads of taste, a light sharpness, and a touch of saltiness. The Artigiano eats like a thicker pizza the place the crust and cheese are the dominant elements. The basic actually options the sauce because the star.

So What’s the Distinction?

The primary distinction between the 2 is that the Artigiano options extra cheese on it, making it a heavier pizza. It additionally adjustments the proportions of the dough, sauce, cheese ratio. This ratio causes the sauce to take a again seat and a possibility for cheese lovers to take pleasure in extra of that tacky goodness! There’s additionally a distinction in how the pies are baked. One is positioned within the oven as soon as and baked to completion. The opposite is baked with sure elements on it to start out, eliminated, topped once more, after which goes again within the oven to complete baking. Are you able to inform which one?

Reviewing Joe’s Authentic Pizza

• Restaurant: Joe’s Pizza
• Location: 5 W Church St, Nanticoke, PA 18634
• Date: March 2014
• Pizza Ordered: Giant Traditional Pizza
• Eat In/Take Out: Eat In

Pizza is Much like: Stuccio’s, Angelo’s, Jerry’s, Dough Co.

Reviewing Joe’s Artigiano Pizza

• Restaurant: Joe’s Pizza
• Date: June 2023
• Pizza Ordered: Giant Artigiano Pizza

My Evaluate of Joe’s Pizza in 2013 – The Story of How Nothing Has Ever Modified (and that’s a superb factor)!

Joe’s Pizza – The Little Pizza Store That May

I first came upon about Joe’s Pizza in Nanticoke when he was beneficiant sufficient to answer my open request on social media to pizzeria homeowners to donate 100 free slices of pizza to NEPA BlogCon 2013, which is an area blogger and social media convention.  Joe stepped as much as the plate and got here by way of with 100 slices for the BlogCon attendees who loved their cuts.  Joe’s Pizza is likely one of the most energetic NEPA pizzerias on fb, and his webmaster has made Joe a web-based celeb of types, so I observe alongside along with his antics and watch what’s occurring, however I don’t get to Nanticoke a lot so it took me about 6 months to get down and really evaluate the pizza.

The primary woman my girlfriend (now spouse!) heard and skim a lot about Joe’s generosity that she lastly made an government choice and stated we’re making the trek south to strive Joe’s Pizza out as soon as and for all.  Once we arrived, we walked right into a easy eating space with about 5 tables, a number of coolers with numerous chilly grownup drinks accessible for takeout, and naturally Joe standing in his kitchen in entrance of the ovens.  The half wall surrounding the pizza making counter allowed us to be greeted and entertained by Joe himself as he went about his enterprise dealing with all features of the operation.  

Pizza and a Dialog With a Legend

When Joe took our order, he advisable that we strive the Artigiano pizza, which is actually the normal pizza with slightly extra cheese and sauce however tastes a bit completely different as a result of it’s baked “the outdated manner.”  As a fellow pizza maker, I couldn’t agree extra, you could take the identical actual elements and put together two pizzas every just a bit otherwise, and each will style distinctive from the opposite pizza.  And who had been we to choose some other pizza in addition to the proprietor’s selection?!  

Whereas Joe was making the pizza, we realized so much about pizza, life, his enterprise, household, and a complete lot extra.  Consuming at Joe’s will not be a proper eating expertise, however it’s a healthful, enjoyable, partaking, and neighborly tour which we very a lot loved.  The eating space’s simplicity is stuffed with Joe’s charasmatic and pleasant persona and that makes all of the distinction.

Joe the One Man Present

When the pizza was finished, Joe “the one man present” himself introduced it to our desk and awaited our response.  I attempted the primary slice noting that the pie had slightly weight to it due to the additional cheese and barely dense dough.  I took my first chunk and there was a really satisfying crunch and texture to the pizza.  I very a lot loved the hearty sauce that wasn’t too chunky, however wasn’t too easy both.  It had a number of physique to it, was properly seasoned, and properly balanced.  I’ve to think about this to be one of many extra distinctive sauces I’ve come throughout.  

Because the sauce consumed a lot of my curiosity, I sadly didn’t pay a lot consideration to the cheese so I should go to once more to find out what Joe’s secret cheese is.  The crust jogged my memory of a dense bread, form of like a sourdough as a result of it had such a pleasant crunch and nice taste.  Total we very a lot loved the pizza, particularly the primary woman.  After our analysis, we gave Joe our sincere verbal report of what we thought and he knowledgeable us that he had one thing particular for us to strive earlier than we left – it was his signature stromboli which apparently is sort of widespread.

The Stromboli of All Stromboli’s!

I assumed, properly how distinctive can a stromboli be?  It’s only a pocket of dough with cheese, meat and greens in it.  Boy was I improper.  Joe served up a wonderfully browned stromboli filled with numerous meats, greens, and seasonings in such a manner that I instantly knew I used to be going to be impressed earlier than I even tried it.  I wouldn’t do that tremendous stromboli justice if I attempted to call the elements, however give Joe a name and he’ll let you understand what’s in it.  

The various flavors and textures had been so fantastic, it wasn’t greasy, it wasn’t overwhelmed with cheese, and each chunk was like a brand new taste journey.  Coupling this stromboli with Joe’s signature sauce to dip in made for what I’d think about to be the proper boli.  I’ve made a number of strombolis in my day, however none that had been wherever close to this caliber!  I extremely suggest that the NEPA Nation give the “Little Pizza Store That May” a strive.  Whether or not you’re a pizza lover, stromboli fanatic, or just wish to be entertained by Joe himself, cease over and say good day.  You gained’t be sorry! 

Reviewing Joe’s Pizza in 2014

• Restaurant: Joe’s Pizza
• Location: 5 W Church St, Nanticoke, PA 18634
• Date: March 2014
• Pizza Ordered: Giant Artigiano Pizza
• Eat In/Take Out: Eat In