Inside: The Change Witch is usually a enjoyable Halloween custom in your youngsters. Listed below are the do’s and don’t for making it work.

Years in the past, I used to be chatting with a neighbor about Halloween and the mountain of sweet that enters our lives yearly after Trick-or-Treating.
“The Change Witch comes and takes a few of our sweet,” she mentioned slyly.
Say what?
What’s the Change Witch?
I got here to study that the Change Witch is a mysterious enchantress who arrives on Halloween night time after bedtime.
Youngsters set out some of their sweet for her on the finish of the night time. She takes the items of sweet and deposits one thing particular of their place.
The annual deluge of suckers and fun-sized Butterfingers stresses out numerous mother and father–so is the Change Witch the reply?
What The Change Witch can educate youngsters
In addition to being a enjoyable custom, the Change Witch idea has a helpful life lesson that numerous grown-ups may use too: Find out how to put a worth on what you actually like–and to not waste your time on the stuff you don’t.
How typically have you ever been handed an enormous piece of mediocre, store-bought birthday cake and simply ate it as a result of it was there? Or scarfed down a second slice of pizza despite the fact that it wasn’t superb?
Placing a precedence on our favourite meals–and never losing time on what we don’t–is a ability we’d like in a world the place meals is in all places.
It’s additionally a pleasant means for youngsters with probably life-threatening meals allergy symptoms to swap what they’ll’t eat for a particular shock.

Do you have to do the Change Witch?
Personally, my boys liked the Change Witch. They liked the thriller of it. They liked waking up the following morning to see what she introduced.
They liked dividing their trick-or-treat stash into piles: Hold. Commerce. Change Witch.
Ultimately, they had been nonetheless left with a large pile, which they’d eat a bit bit at a time over the course of many weeks.
Some years, our personal Change Witch introduced a enjoyable toy, e book, or five-dollar invoice. Extra typically than she likes to confess, she raced to Goal on Halloween night time earlier than it closed as a result of she forgot to plan forward. Ahem.
In the event you’re contemplating doing the Change Witch together with your youngsters too, listed here are some do’s and don’ts:
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: How I Deal with Halloween Sweet Craziness

DO make the Change Witch non-compulsory
The Change Witch is alleged to be a enjoyable custom within the spirit of the Tooth Fairy or the Easter Bunny. She’s a very good witch, not a punishment–there’s no disgrace in liking and wanting sweet.
DON’T make candy the enemy
Sure, Trick of Treating can carry a large quantity of sweet into your home. And sure, there’s numerous sugar consumption taking place on the night time of Halloween. Sweet is an enormous a part of Halloween–and that’s okay. It’s pure and regular to have a good time some events with meals. And positive, glow-sticks and plastic spider rings are good to go out for Trick-or-Treating. However there’s little doubt that for most children, sweet is the principle occasion.
So in the event you demonize Halloween sweet or ask your child to offer all of it away, it’s complicated. Your baby labored exhausting operating from home to accommodate to earn his haul. Wasn’t that the purpose of dressing up and going house-to-house, of sifting by the pile and buying and selling favorites amongst associates–isn’t it what they’ve been ready for all month?
DO let your youngsters determine what they offer the Change Witch
In our home, my youngsters left her the stuff they felt form of “meh” about–what they could eat if it was there however didn’t favor. In different phrases, our Change Witch’s broomstick was made largely of Mounds, Good & Loads, and Necco Wafers. My youngsters typically tossed in what they’ve a surplus of as nicely.
DON’T pilfer your youngsters’ sweet with out asking
Mother and father stealing their youngsters’ Halloween sweet is a long-running joke, however I encourage you to ask first so your baby doesn’t must really feel obsessive or protecting of her stash. Youngsters who fear their mother and father will take their stash might find yourself sneaking and hiding sweet–or believing the message that they’ll’t be trusted round sweet or different sweets. And asking your baby first for a chunk of sweet provides them extra observe sharing–and also you get one thing yummy!
DO take into account letting your baby get pleasure from Trick-or-Deal with with out interference
I’ve seen too many mother and father arguing with their youngsters throughout Trick-or-Treating about what number of items of sweet they’re allowed to eat. You must do what works greatest for your loved ones, however personally, I all the time let my youngsters have as a lot as they wished on Halloween night time. In the event that they felt sick, we talked about how overeating could cause bellyaches.
YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE: 20 Allergy-Pleasant Halloween Treats

Questions in regards to the Change Witch
What in case your youngsters aren’t on board?
In case your youngsters don’t need to give away a few of their sweet, don’t drive the problem. It’s necessary to belief our children–and for our children to belief us. In any other case, you might find yourself with a baby who sneaks sweet and different “forbidden” meals and feels disgrace that she desires it.
How a lot sweet ought to the Change Witch take?
That’s as much as you and your youngsters. Keep in mind–we don’t need our children feeling cheated or tricked out of the sweet they labored for.
Can’t I simply throw my youngsters’ sweet away?
My vote isn’t any. Hey, I get it–it’s numerous sweet! And also you simply need that pile gone so there’s no begging or negotiating within the days forward, proper? So that you wait a day for the sugar-hangover to put on off, allow them to have just a few items, then take the remainder to the workplace–or dump it within the trash.
I positively perceive the inclination. When my youngsters had been youthful, I did some stealth “sweet relocation” myself. However I’ve since modified my tune. As a result of that received’t educate your youngsters something, besides to not belief mother and pa!
Taking away your baby’s Halloween sweet stash sends a transparent message: I don’t belief you with this.

So how do I handle the pile of sweet that’s left?
Listed below are some concepts:
- Make a plan collectively. The day after Trick-or-Treating, speak about what you suppose is an inexpensive method to deal with the remainder of the stash. Does one or two items a day sound doable? Would your baby favor to pack them in her lunch field or get pleasure from them at dwelling? My two boys’ Halloween sweet was saved in separate baggage in a cabinet they may entry. We determined collectively what an inexpensive portion was. Once they had been little, it was one piece a day, which labored more often than not. They may have their deal with every time they wished: of their lunchbox, after faculty, after dinner, even WITH dinner. As they bought older, they managed their very own stashes.
- Take away a few of the energy. Sweet isn’t the end-all-be-all if it’s available. Two methods you may take into account attempting: serving the sweet together with dinner (sure, your youngsters might eat the fun-sized bar Snickers, the transfer on to the remainder of the meal and that’s okay!) and sometimes providing as a lot as they need at snack time. These approaches come from feeding professional and dietitian Ellyn Satter. I’ve tried each, and although they’re scary at first, I discovered them very useful (and efficient).
- Bake cookies! In case your youngsters are cool with it, bake this Skillet Cookie collectively utilizing a few of the further sweet.
Backside Line
The Change Witch is usually a enjoyable custom in your youngsters and educate them classes round prioritizing their favorites. However the Change Witch needs to be one thing your youngsters WANT to do, not a sneaky means of eliminating further sweet.